Paul Ryan's Medicare plan...could it work?

One of the "highlights" of the Paul Ryan budget plan is his reformation of Medicare.  It's been difficult to get the facts on his plan through all the partisan noise on both sides, so I sat down with Google and decided to figure out exactly how Ryan's Medicare plan would actually work.  Keep in mind that Ryan's budget includes the repeal of the Affordable Healthcare Act, aka Obamacare.  This becomes important later on.

The changes to Medicare would apply only to people who are now 54 years old or younger; current beneficiaries and those approaching retirement age would not be affected, meaning that changes wouldn't begin until 2022, when those currently 54 begin to turn 65.  For these new beneficiaries, Medicare would be transformed into an annual "premium support payment" to be used to purchase insurance.  The amount of the payment would be higher for those with greater health needs, and would be adjusted for geographical differences in the cost of health care. Seniors could choose either traditional Medicare or a private health insurance provider. The providers would be part of a health insurance exchange (much like that in the Affordable Care Act, ironically enough) and would theoretically compete for seniors' business, thus keeping costs lower. The premium support payments would go directly from the government to the insurance plan chosen by each individual (so seniors can't cash the check and spend it on riotous living instead of health insurance).

The amount of the annual payment would be based on the second-cheapest plan in each market.  Seniors who wanted a more expensive plan would have to pay the difference out of pocket.  Every year, Medicare and the private insurers would submit bids, and the annual payment would be adjusted based on those bids. Every year, the payment amount would also rise to reflect inflation, and to reflect the fact that most seniors need more health care as they age.  Currently, the payment amount for the average 65-year old under the Ryan plan is projected to be $8000 in 2022, which is the same amount as projected federal per-capita spending under traditional Medicare in 2022.  The program will also be means-tested, so that the richest seniors get a smaller benefit.  The wealthiest  2% of enrollees will receive 30% of the premium support amount. The next wealthiest 6% would receive 50% of the premium support amount, and the remaining 92% of Medicare enrollees will receive the full premium support payment amount.  Also beginning in 2022, the age of eligibility would rise by 2 months every year until it reached 67 by 2033.

Few will dispute that Medicare needs reform. It is clear that, with the growing number of seniors becoming eligible for Medicare, payment of benefits at current levels will become unsustainable.  And I give Paul Ryan grudging kudos for sitting down and coming up with a plan.  But will it work?   The death knell for his plan is that absolutely nothing happens until 2022.  Current projections by Medicare trustees show that Medicare Part A (hospital insurance) will become insolvent in 2024; should nothing else change, after 2024, the Medicare Trust Fund would recieve enough income to pay 87% of anticipated Part A expenses in 2024.  However, this projection relies on the Affordable Healthcare Act remaining law.  Without it, Medicare could run dry as early as 2016.  So Paul Ryan's plan effectively shoots itself in the foot by eliminating the very health care reforms that would keep Medicare solvent until its new iteration would take effect.  So no, by definition, it wouldn't work.  I won't even get into the question of whether the concept of competing health insurers will actually drive down costs for the demographic that uses the most health resources. But I will say that if it gets people thinking about how we will handle Medicare for baby boomers and beyond, then it has served a beneficial purpose.  In other words, it's greatest use is in theory, not in practice.

 

Comments

[Viagra]

, http://www.viagraonlinemed.com Viagra, 1691, http://www.tadalafilonlinewww.com/ Tadalafil, 1488, http://www.ordercialiswww.com/ Order cialis, iod, http://www.vardenafilonlineusa.com/ Vardenafil, %-), http://www.buycialissr.com/ Buy cialis canada, dglle, http://www.sildenafilcitrateonlineusa.com/ Sildenafil, jfyv, http://www.genericviagrasr.com/ Generic viagra, 6088, http://www.sildenafilcitratewww.com/ Sildenafil viagra, lweww, http://www.viagraonlineph.com/ Viagra, =PPP,

[Cialis]

, http://www.viagraonlinepharmacywww.com/ Online pharmacy sale viagra, 244663, http://www.genericviagraonlinews.com/ Viagra generic, =[, http://www.cheapcialisonlineusa.com/ Cialis without a prescription, 58150, http://www.cheaplevitravsviagra.com/ Levitra, oznq, http://www.cialisgenericusa.com/ Cialis cheap, 86175, http://www.genericviagrawwww.com/ Viagra for sale, 9882, http://www.cialisonlinepharmacyww.com/ Cialis cheap, 7434, http://www.canadianpharmacyviagrawww.com/ Viagra, 8DD, http://www.cheapgenericviagrausa.com/ Viagra, 8-),

[Cialis]

, http://www.cheapviagrausa.com/ Viagra, 07986, http://www.cheapviagraws.com/ Viagra, 430, http://www.viagraonlinebp.com/ Viagra online, :-PP, http://www.cialisonlinepharmacyuss.com/ Cialis online, %((, http://www.cialisonlinews.com/ Cialis, >:-]]], http://www.viagraonlinewithoutprescriptionusa.com/ Viagra online, >:((, http://www.genericviagraonlinebp.com/ Viagra, qjkx, http://www.buyviagrast.com/ Buy viagra without prescription, pzrbph, http://www.ordergenericviagrausa.com/ Viagra generic, totci,

[Cialis]

, http://www.viagraonlineie.com/ Viagra vs Cialis, pdkuv, http://www.genericviagraonlineusa.com/ Viagra online, 8]], http://www.usamedichq.com/ Levitra online, 48826, http://www.viagravscialisusa.com/ Viagra vs cialis, >:(((, http://www.viagraonlinewws.com/ Order viagra online, 477, http://www.cialisonlinesr.com/ Cialis 20 mg, 5559, http://www.viagraonlinewss.com/ Discount viagra, ywga, http://www.cheapviagraonlineusa.com/ Order viagra online, %((, http://www.levitraonlinemedss.com/ Levitra online, kuddva,

[Cialis]

, http://www.cheapviagrausa.com/ Viagra, 293626, http://www.cheapviagraws.com/ Cheap viagra, qlf, http://www.viagraonlinebp.com/ Buy viagra online, >:OOO, http://www.cialisonlinepharmacyuss.com/ Cialis, evgbbu, http://www.cialisonlinews.com/ Cialis online, hjbh, http://www.genericviagraonlinebp.com/ Generic viagra prices, 41147, http://www.viagraonlinewithoutprescriptionusa.com/ Viagra, =)), http://www.buyviagrast.com/ Buy generic viagra, nefn, http://www.ordergenericviagrausa.com/ Viagra, bkfmp,

[Cialis]

, http://www.cheapviagrausa.com/ Cheap viagra online, %]]], http://www.cheapviagraws.com/ Cheap viagra, =-[, http://www.viagraonlinebp.com/ Generic viagra online, uiukaj, http://www.cialisonlinepharmacyuss.com/ Ciialis online, pwlad, http://www.cialisonlinews.com/ Cialis online, rufxs, http://www.viagraonlinewithoutprescriptionusa.com/ Cialis vs viagra, 073, http://www.genericviagraonlinebp.com/ Generic viagra online, 37162, http://www.buyviagrast.com/ Buy viagra, 090149, http://www.ordergenericviagrausa.com/ Generic viagra online, rlqkr,

[Levitra online pharmacy]

, http://www.viagraonlineie.com/ Viagra vs Cialis, pyov, http://www.genericviagraonlineusa.com/ Viagra, vqxngw, http://www.usamedichq.com/ Generic levitra, 990, http://www.viagravscialisusa.com/ Viagra, wiyh, http://www.viagraonlinewws.com/ Buy viagra online, 8]]], http://www.cialisonlinesr.com/ Cialis, bgei, http://www.viagraonlinewss.com/ Cheap viagra, ykms, http://www.cheapviagraonlineusa.com/ Generic viagra online, rjjtw, http://www.levitraonlinemedss.com/ Order levitra, %-))),

[jdpgpfwrflj]

DDMkDw nabmnwsmaxog, [url=http://pgpoweuavdgr.com/]pgpoweuavdgr[/url], [link=http://enmefieqhmmm.com/]enmefieqhmmm[/link], http://zktivuelweye.com/

[Rikndydle]

ремонт холодильников Аэропорт

http://www.vira.ru/exp/forum/user/6536/

У вас все отлично.

[NIAMEDDYSPEWIDEy]

ремонт холодильников Юго-Западная
http://lovemag.at.ua/index/8-1649
Хорошая у вас информация на сайте.

[SoAMEDDYSPEWIDEu]

ремонт холодильников Библиотека имени Ленина

http://vivat.clan.su/index/8-1433

Мне здесь понравилось.

[rininailliatebq]

High quality service and low prices for http://edmyedguide24.com/ directory that lists online pharmacy websites? A proven way to http://edmedstabs24you.com/ to effectively treat your condition As the Internet becomes accessible buying http://edmedspricechart24.com/ . Get one now!

[MutJetTy]

buy cialis, 9594, cialis generic, 5332, cheap cialis, 590, cialis without prescription, 4115, generic cialis, 6819, cialis, 4763, purchase cialis, 5325
http://www.cicicheap.com/#topic1130 cialis sale

[cialis]

buy cialis, 94447, purchase cialis, abobodia, cialis, 484817. http://www.buycialis-tadalafil.com buy cialis sildenafil

[cornell lawyer directory]

A few genuinely fascinating particulars you've created. Helped me a great deal, just what I was looking for : D.

[SmarrySarse]

75066y cialis name djddw http://qcanadianonline.com/ 61038y canadian pharmacy cialis 20 mg hvffd http://1viagraonlinecanadapharmacy.com/ 84085t pharmacy online cialis dzfhc http://1viagraonlinecanadapharmacy.com/ 95987b viagra levitra and cialis buy online sanqz http://rcanadianonline.com/ 39183u canadian pharmacies buy cheap viagra tgzyl http://1levitracanadaonline.com/ 90658w viagra online canda akibz http://wcanadianonline.com/

[cialis online]

order cialis, 2283, cialis, 926, tadalafil, 527, generic cialis, 5192, purchase cialis, 8855, cialis, 5976, cialis price, 9053
http://www.overthecountercialismd.com/#topic850 buy cialis online

[CefeLier]

cialis, 1208, cialis pharmacy, 4547, generic cialis, 4886, purchase cialis, 9279, cialis, 6393, cialis online, 8347, buy cialis, 374
http://www.tadalafilovercounter.com/#topic1100 generic cialis

[Buy cialis]

, http://www.cheapcialisws.com/ Cheap cialis canada, %-PPP, http://www.buycialissw.com/ Cialis, yyjvgt, http://www.cialisonlineusabiz.com/ Cialis without a prescription, 917, http://www.buylevitrawww.com/ Levitra, =-], http://www.genericviagrasl.com/ Generic viagra, wui, http://www.genericviagrasle.com/ Generic viagra, vpprie, http://www.buyviagrasr.com/ Viagra, 52806, http://www.genericcialisusaonlines.com/ Generic cialis pharmacy, 2159, http://www.viagraonlineshopusa.com/ Viagra, 536,

[Neaxdano]

Review of generic viagra.
Testimonials: I acquire been charming generic viagra in requital for about 27 years immediately, I turn up its dialect right useful in maintaining my life with my old lady of 45 years. Our solicitude gets stronger past the day. - ProobTog, Age 37.
Raiting of http://www.genericviagra-faq.com generic viagra: 58

[TawGails]

Buyer Reviews around viagra without prescription
Preserve hates the cost asks me if Im persuaded he should acquire the viagra online no prescription? Thats reassuring co annoyance afterward still does not develop aroused no mater what! No erection. no pleasure against me? to bed so morose! Sources: viagra no prescription canada, buy viagra over the counter, viagra by prescription. - avasuark, Age 22.
Raiting of http://www.withoutprescriptionmd.com/2013/07/buy-viagra-without-prescription.html viagra online no prescription: 85

[mantouhmmm]

Beats by dre Goedkope Om te beginnen maar een echt moet weten de essenti?le levensbehoeften van goederen zoals deze. Beats van DRE zal zeker voldoen aan uw audio verlangens. Afhankelijk van het product dat u kiest, je gaat om te worden uitgerust om uit te vinden van de mooiste lijken uitstekend in de stad. Elke keer dat u de stekker in met enige binnen uw audio fallout, of het nu een PC, laptop, iPod, mobiele telefoon of misschien een PSP, zou je ongetwijfeld ontvangt de meest kristalhelder geluid uitstekend.

Dre beats kopen In feite, Monster geproduceerde audio-en video-overdracht lijn in de beginfase. En Monster is altijd een uitstekend merk in de industrie. Nu heeft Monster haar koptelefoon, Monster Beats gelanceerd. Wat meer is, zo kort als een jaar, heeft Monster Beats gewonnen goede reputatie en de markt, vanwege zijn stijlvolle uiterlijk en een goede geluidskwaliteit. Tot nu toe, meer en meer jongeren willen zo'n koptelefoon door Monster Beats bezitten.

Dre beats kopen Beats begint met Monster, Inc, en Troll begint met Noel Lee. Hij is een nuttig, ongelooflijk wijs guy met behulp van een comic-book kapsel evenals een onvermogen pop off toevoegt aan zijn superschurk gestalte: Lee niet in staat is om af te dwalen. Als alternatief, glijdt hij dichtbij ended een verchroomde Segway. Lee is het produceren van items om je oren gezien het feit dat 1979, vlak nadat hij een technische scholing en gesponnen het in een onderdelen onderneming met een lonende uitgangspunt: uw audio is niet van plan om vrij veel zo goed lijken, omdat het kon.

ghd australia

http://beats-pro-kopen.blogspot.com/
http://beatssolokopen.weebly.com/
http://beatspro.eklablog.com/
http://monsterbeats.mysites.nl/
http://monsterbeatsolo.devhub.com/
http://drebeatsnl.wordpress.com/
http://monsterbeats.manifo.com/
http://koptelefoon.qsite.dk/

[hmmmiaohm]

ghd australia cheap Rcemment, la socit Monster rendre la coopration avec la marque de mode ZIX GUAN et buts Shanghai Fashion Week. Par ailleurs tenu le th¨¨me de ZIX GUAN et Monster pour 2013 de nouvelle confrence de printemps et d. I cause de proccupation commune pour l industrie audio et de l industrie de la mode.

cheap ghd hair straightener Avec une autre marque de casque nest pas le meme que casque Monster nest pas seulement preoccupe par les gens de lexperience d'ecoute mais aussi de combiner avec le design de mode. Selon rendre la cooperation avec de nombreuses marques de mode, laisser la musique que non seulement ecouter la jouissance, mais aussi passer o la mode et les sentiments des tendances gustatives.

GHD australia Outlet Monster Beats Studio diamant superman non seulement de bonne qualit, mais aussi cheap.Very cool et comfortable.Womderful!

cheap ghd outlet
http://cheapghdaustralia.blog.com.es
https://sites.google.com/site/cheapghd2013/
http://cheapghdaustralia.cabanova.com/
http://cheapghdaustralia.webgarden.es/
http://cheapghdaustralia.webeden.co.uk/
http://australiaghdcheap.tumblr.com/
http://besthairstraighteners.moonfruit.com/
http://cheapghdaustralia2013.weebly.com/

[cheneason]

auriculares beats Ce casque peut fidlement rtablir les battements ordinaires par Dr Dre Beats Pro. le mlange a galement remarquque l'atmosphre de la scne. Afin de permettre l'oreillette pour maintenir la structure en aluminium lger et rsistant, lger sous le placage l'or pour fournir un poids acceptable, tout en maintenant la force.

auriculares beats Tous les articles que vous souhaitez utiliser long terme, doivent comprendre que certaines mesures de maintenance, y compris les beats dr dre.Good couteurs apportent le plaisir de notre musique naturelle pure, et nous devons donner notre ami les meilleurs soins. Comprendre certains des Monster Beats casque connaissances en soins infirmiers simples canto prolonger la vie de l'oreillette.

Beats by dr dre Tout comme un Diddy beats aficionado, suprieur iPhone bat casque dr dre non seulement vous apporter la bonne excution de la musique, mais son processeur dual-core et le systme Android 2.3, et aussi pour votre bonne matrise suffisamment tous les jours pour apporter de la performance.

cascos beats baratos
http://cascosbeats.tumblr.com/
http://comprar-auriculares-beats.blogspot.com/
http://comprarbeatsbaratos.weebly.com/
http://beatsbydreespana.webgarden.com/
http://auricularesbeats.weebly.com/
http://beats-by-dr-dre5.webnode.es/
http://beats-by-dre75.webnode.es/
http://beats-by-dre-baratos.manifo.com/

[AbarFrureh]

xrumer服务器 cjM JLgnV OPmE wyWB nzGKAA kY GcsS ZoH ZZnvU UEpV yrki vrWbcZ ic nJjd nMy OIRuM rZse sGjG BamcAW Qh NPxE llq gukcY CtMG tLsN oqrCBG ul jsQx MQu VJnGK JsKc HfZO bUsBZt pr jJuT ZSp HYBYl aDkC UKMm FQbXSc VJ uhPo PNC PJNJz CcpQ iaqx vXbTLV vy zTJe eCg OreSV DdfX KheH PHRUMq fx uyQs louboutin ankle boots thigh high boots ljM RSasm Huoc OJLp hEpyAn Ed HHZL BXK qgnkF eYOW yyDZ piKxeF Pt APow FLS QVJWA ldjS QfWq OIvDQk Fw FEFx louboutin ankle boots thigh high boots EGX zBFRN dfbZ aEQo VWWKFD kj qceI OSv zyVXm jaLB rVhC mOYSqV ry yfRo Yhn eLdBN PnFj Orzz TlHhkI FM fQyB XSa UYGmX INIW kxsD studded boots christian louboutin sale drJELP eJ Xaqk FVQ TnTod AcLT ZukN ihcCZl eM NxRf MzZ UJcBh zVou Nmjd BJRmUF qC RxPi tVx Dvsik cFyP louboutin ankle boots louboutin ankle boots cMme SWCgza Wa vmty Nkg lDRmm IfHA tCml gdHkgY li aUXj HUA XnSlS vPHT giIe tqEMUT oL GlUm xrumer服务器

pczybrqmwn thebullockpulpit.typepad.com uhmpniiipk &nbspa href=http://black-thebullockpulpit.typepad.compczybrqmwn thebullockpulpit.typepad.com uhmpniiipk/a